Situation
Our Recommendation
Why
Single area leak — chimney, pipe boot, or valley
Repair
Isolated damage with a clear cause. A targeted repair stops the problem and extends roof life by years.
Missing or blown-off shingles after a storm
Repair
If the rest of the roof is in good shape, replacing the affected section is fast, affordable, and effective.
Roof under 15 years old with localized damage
Repair
Plenty of life left. A repair now protects your investment and delays replacement by 10+ years.
Roof 20+ years old with widespread granule loss
Replace
The shingles are at end of life. Repairs become a recurring cost — replacement is more economical long-term.
Multiple active leaks in different areas
Replace
Multiple failure points usually mean the system is failing overall. Patching one leads to another.
Insurance claim approved for full replacement
Replace
If insurance is paying, take the full replacement. You'll get a new roof with a full warranty for your deductible.
Storm damage — not sure what's covered
Inspect First
We document everything before you file. You may qualify for a full replacement — don't repair before you know.












